MAYBELLINENew York Line Express Eyeliner, Ebony Black 901, 0.035 Ounce

I ordered this pencil liner in black, and I couldn't be happier with the quality of this product. I love the intense pigment -it goes on smoothly, and makes my eyes pop. It also has a nifty smudger tip, which is great for blending when I want a less defined look. I don't have the steadiest hand when lining my top lids, so the smudger tip has extra value for me. I can dip it in makeup remover oil to remove the line if I mess up, or correct it, without redoing the whole lid. The pencil also sharpens well, and the pigment stays steadfast. Awesome value, and a great price point. This is my new go-to pencil liner.

This is a hard product to beat for the price. It goes on nice and smooth while maintaining a nice point which allowed for a really nice wing look. For blending the product smudges really well and the attached blender worked nicely especially on the lower lash line. It even stayed nicely after it set. I would recommend this to anyone looking for an effective and affordable eyeliner.

I wish this item was still sold in stores! It's the best eyeline pencil out there. It's easy to use and glides effortlessly over the eye line...it's also easy to sharpen!

I really love the softness of this black pencil eyeliner. The only problem is, the tip breaks off easily when you try to sharpen it. Other than that, I love how it goes on. I wonder if refrigeration will help the tip not break when sharpening?

This is my favorite eyeliner! It is easily sharpened as it is a pencil which allows for precise no-mess application. The color is spot on as advertised and does not clump or break during application. Also, once it is on, it stays on until you're ready to take it off, which I do easily with my make-up remover wipes. This is great because other, non-pencil eyeliners can be much more difficult to take off and end up smudging everywhere. Not this eyeliner though. Highly recommended!

# Not quite as intensely dark as I had hoped (like the define-a-line Ebony Black, the green-black plastic mechanical pencil). I had to reapply once or twice throughout the day - probably would have reapplied more often, but it started to irritate my eyes. Goes on smooth, relatively easy to apply - as long as you don't expect it to be really dark. I wouldn't call this Ebony Black.# It may cause irritation *sometimes* but I can't say for sure because on most days it feels just fine. Besides, this is something subjective that's usually different for each person.# I'll most likely go back to the define-a-line though, because of the intensity of the color as well as the convenience of not having to sharpen regularly (as with this one).# Which brings me to my main issue with this pencil - no matter how carefully I sharpen, it breaks off or crumbles. So you'll run out a lot faster than expected. NOT a good value, even at $4 minus $1.50 (coupon).

So I'm not gonna pretend to know anything about make up I strictly bought this for cosplay purposes. Pointed end of the pencil broke off immediately after I took it out of the packaging not a big deal I have a pencil sharpener so just heads up have a pencil sharpener. I actually used this first on my eyebrows just to see how well it would fill them in and I was pleased works with mustaches and beards too (just fyi). Pretty easy to remove little water and wipe away.I'm not sure if this is an everyday product but it's good for casual use and its affordable so I say 5 stars

I LOVE THIS EYELINER!!!! Delivers such intense color and the blending is so easy with the contour smudger. Its applies on smoothly so easy to apply with just one stroke.!! Effective and affordable.